Major technology companies are facing intense scrutiny from online safety experts who argue that current efforts to comply with the United Kingdom’s Online Safety Act (OSA) are insufficient. During a recent session before Parliament’s Communications and Digital Committee, witnesses testified that while platforms like Google, Microsoft, Meta, and ByteDance appear to be meeting the letter of the law, they are failing to provide meaningful protection for vulnerable users and victims of online harm.
A primary point of contention involves the inconsistent application of search engine downranking for harmful content. Legal experts highlighted that while platforms may effectively suppress specific search terms, they often fail to address synonymous or adjacent phrases. For instance, while explicit terms related to non-consensual sexual content are sometimes heavily restricted, variations such as "unwilling" or "unwanted" often remain easily discoverable. Critics argue that a systematic approach to filtering these related terms is lacking, allowing harmful material to bypass existing safety measures.
The committee also heard concerns regarding the visibility of websites that openly advertise the distribution of illegal content. Experts suggested that these platforms frequently escape the notice of both major search engines and the regulatory bodies tasked with oversight. Because these sites often remain accessible via virtual private networks (VPNs) that circumvent age-verification protocols, the material remains available to users even when it is technically restricted in specific jurisdictions.
Beyond search engine visibility, there is growing alarm over the declining efficacy of content-takedown requests. Data provided by the charity Refuge indicates a significant drop in the success rate of reports submitted by "Trusted Flaggers"—specialized entities that work directly with platforms to remove harmful content. According to these figures, the success rate for such reports fell from 53.7 percent prior to November 2025 to just 18.2 percent over the past year.
The data specifically highlighted a sharp decline in responsiveness from Meta. According to the figures cited, the success rate for reports submitted to the company by the charity’s team has dropped to zero percent since November 2025. While Meta did not provide a direct response to these specific claims, the company’s own Community Standards Enforcement Report for the second quarter of 2026 states that it removed 27.8 million posts related to adult nudity and sexual activity. However, observers noted that this internal reporting does not categorize content specifically related to violence against women and girls, making it difficult to verify the company's performance in that specific area.
The parliamentary discussion reflects a broader frustration among safety advocates regarding the real-world impact of the OSA more than a year after its implementation. This sentiment aligns with previous testimony from the Children’s Commissioner for England, who stated in September that the legislation has yet to produce a tangible reduction in children’s access to harmful online material.
To address these gaps, experts are calling for more robust mechanisms to empower individuals. Currently, victims often lack a direct legal pathway to demand the removal of harmful images or to seek redress from perpetrators. Witnesses pointed to the civil redress system in British Columbia, Canada, as a potential model. That system allows individuals to pursue legal action for the swift removal of content and provides a framework for seeking compensation for damages.
As of the conclusion of the committee session, Google, Microsoft, and TikTok had not responded to requests for comment regarding the criticisms raised by the panel. The testimony underscores a widening gap between the regulatory expectations set by the UK government and the operational realities faced by those attempting to report and remove harmful content from major digital platforms.





