The New York City Council passed legislation on November 12 that seeks to curb the practice of surveillance pricing, a business model that utilizes personal data and algorithmic analysis to set individualized prices for goods and services. Known as Introduction 891-A, the bill is currently awaiting signature by the mayor. If enacted, the law will take effect one year from the date of signing, establishing a regulatory framework that prohibits the use of personal information to influence pricing structures for consumers within the city.
The legislation specifically targets the collection, sale, and sharing of personal data when such activities are intended to facilitate these discriminatory pricing tactics. By shifting the focus away from market-based fluctuations, the bill aims to distinguish surveillance pricing from traditional dynamic pricing. While dynamic pricing typically adjusts costs based on external factors like supply, demand, or inventory availability, surveillance pricing relies on the granular profiling of individual users to determine what a specific person might be willing to pay.
The scope of the data leveraged for these pricing models is extensive. According to findings released by the Federal Trade Commission in January 2025, modern pricing tools are capable of analyzing highly specific behavioral metrics, including a user’s browsing history, geographic location, shopping habits, and even subtle interactions like mouse movements or items abandoned in digital shopping carts. Research indicates that these data-driven pricing pipelines are already in widespread use, with intermediaries providing these services to hundreds of clients across industries ranging from apparel to grocery retail.
A central concern addressed by the bill is the information asymmetry between the seller and the consumer. While companies can build complex profiles to assess a customer’s price sensitivity, the consumer remains largely unaware of how their personal data is being interpreted or why they are being quoted a specific price. This system does not necessarily penalize only the wealthy; instead, it targets perceived willingness to pay. As a result, a consumer with limited financial resources who has an urgent need for a product may be charged more than a wealthier shopper who is identified as a bargain hunter.
The legislation includes specific carve-outs to ensure that standard retail practices are not inadvertently criminalized. The bill explicitly permits the continuation of legitimate loyalty and rewards programs. Furthermore, it allows for discounts offered to clearly defined groups, such as seniors, veterans, and teachers, provided these programs do not function as a front for unauthorized surveillance pricing.
Beyond the immediate financial impact on consumers, the bill addresses the broader privacy implications of large-scale data collection. The reliance on personal data for pricing models necessitates the aggregation of sensitive information, which increases the risk of unauthorized disclosure and the potential for companies to make invasive inferences about an individual’s life. By restricting the use of this data for pricing, the city aims to reduce the incentive for companies to harvest and trade such detailed consumer profiles.
The passage of this bill represents a significant regulatory step in addressing how digital footprints are monetized. As the legislation moves toward the mayor’s desk, it signals an intent to prioritize consumer transparency over the opaque algorithmic calculations that have become increasingly common in the digital marketplace. Once the law takes effect, businesses operating in New York City will be required to ensure their pricing algorithms comply with these new privacy-focused standards or face potential legal consequences for the misuse of consumer data.





